This happened the summer after graduation before my freshman year at college , with my girlfriend I met sophomore year and dated throughout High School and my first 2 years of college. We were both virgins at 18, and very horny. We lived in a really small town with one drugstore. She lived about 1/2 mile from me and I was at her house all the time. On weekends I’d be there late after her folks went to bed. We would be laying on the couch watching TV, I’d be playing with her pussy and clit and she’d have my cock out fondling it under a throw blanket.
I so wanted to stick my cock in her wet pussy. She had sucked me a few times, and I had licked her clit some, but we were just exploring. We had no birth control, and back then the condoms were all behind the counter in the drug store, the druggist, being the only one in town, knew all the families, so getting condoms was not an option.
So one night I convinced her after some really heavy petting to let me slide my cock inside her. I promised to slide it in and not move. She said ok! I remember vividly opening her lips and sliding my already soaked with precum slowly in. I remember she gasped at one point but said it was ok. Her pussy felt all warm and buttery enveloping my cock. It was pure heaven.
We lay there like that for what seemed like hours, but was probably like 10 minutes, my cock throbbing to my heartbeat inside her. Finally, I pulled out and she would jerk me to orgasm. I remember walking home grinning ear to ear thinking I was no longer a virgin, but it would be quite sometime later before we ever had proper birth control and we actually fucked and I came inside her. I wouldn’t trade that memory for anything!